Comprehensive vs third party, fire and theft: what each one covers
Comprehensive cover pays for damage to your car and others'. Third party, fire and theft covers your car only if it is stolen or catches fire.
Next step: Compare quotes from registered providers. Free, no obligation. Compare car insurance quotes
Comprehensive car insurance covers damage to your own car, damage you cause to other people’s property, and theft or fire. Third party, fire and theft covers the damage you cause to others, plus your own car only if it is stolen or catches fire. The difference matters most when you cause an accident: with third party, fire and theft, you pay to fix your own car.
What comprehensive cover usually includes
- Accident damage to your car, whether or not you were at fault
- Theft and hijacking
- Fire, hail and flood damage
- Damage you cause to other people’s cars or property (third party liability)
Most policies add optional extras such as car hire, windscreen cover or credit shortfall cover. Each extra adds to the premium.
What third party, fire and theft includes
- Damage you cause to other people’s cars or property
- Your own car if it is stolen or hijacked
- Your own car if it is damaged by fire
It does not pay to repair your car after an accident or hail storm.
Third party only
The most basic option covers only the damage you cause to others. Your own car is not covered at all.
How to choose
Ask yourself three questions:
- Could you afford to repair or replace your car tomorrow? If not, comprehensive cover protects you from the biggest loss.
- Is the car financed? If so, the bank will almost certainly require comprehensive cover.
- What is the car worth compared with the yearly premium? On an older, low-value car, third party, fire and theft can make more sense.
Compare like with like
When you compare quotes, check that each one has the same:
- Cover type
- Excess amounts (the part of each claim you pay yourself)
- Value basis (retail, market or trade value)
- Optional extras
A cheaper quote often has a higher excess or fewer extras.
Check the insurer is authorised
Car insurance in South Africa must be sold by an authorised financial services provider (FSP). You can check an FSP number on the FSCA website. If you have a complaint an insurer won’t resolve, you can take it to the National Financial Ombud Scheme.
This guide is general information, not financial advice. Read the policy wording before you buy.
Ready to compare? Compare quotes from registered providers. Free, no obligation. Compare car insurance quotes
Frequently asked questions
Is third party, fire and theft cheaper than comprehensive?
Usually, because the insurer pays out in fewer situations. Whether it is good value depends on what your car is worth and whether you could afford to repair or replace it yourself.
Can I take third party cover on a financed car?
Most finance agreements require comprehensive cover until the loan is paid off, because the bank owns the car. Check your finance contract before you choose.
Does comprehensive cover include a rental car after a claim?
Not always. Car hire is often an optional extra. Read the policy schedule or ask the insurer before you need it.